Update: See the "live" dev site for the latest work on the new site.
Nick and I have started working on some mockups for the post-Maker Faire version of the AYL website. In the event that new visitors want to weigh in, we thought we'd put the discussion up here to get additional feedback.
Here's what I am working on so far for the home page:
(screenshot removed)
Inner pages (blog posts, project pages, project categories, etc) will use the same top navbar and white background. I am working on those mockups right now.
Project lists will look similar to what they are now. For blog posts, we are planning to create something fairly minimalist, similar to this person's blog. For individual project pages with instructions, we want to emulate the straight-forward layouts that the Make: Projects site uses.